Are the Oscars a mediocre ceremony that fails to nominate and reward masterpieces?

The claim that the Oscars are a mediocre ceremony that fails to nominate and reward masterpieces is subjective and often debated. The 2025 Oscars have faced criticism for various reasons, including controversies surrounding specific films like "Emilia Pérez," which, despite receiving multiple nominations, has been criticized for its portrayal of the transgender community and other cultural issues ABC7 New York. However, the Oscars continue to be a significant event in the film industry, recognizing a wide range of films and performances, as seen in the diverse nominations for 2025 CNN.